Are We Making Life Easier or Making Ourselves Less Capable?

What convenience, comfort, and AI may be teaching us about growth, human connection, and the meaning of joy.
We've spent generations finding ways to make life easier. We've invented machines to reduce physical labor, technologies to simplify everyday tasks, and systems to make us safer, more comfortable, and more efficient.
And now, with artificial intelligence, we're entering a time where technology can do more than ever. It can help us think, solve problems, make decisions, and even automate things we once thought required only human abilities. Most of which is extraordinary progress. But I've been thinking about something that makes me a little uncomfortable.
Maybe I'm getting a little old, but what if some of the experiences we're working to eliminate are the very things that help us become capable? And what happens to our ability to find meaning and joy in our lives when we no longer have to struggle?
An Old Question in a New World
My thinking about this didn't begin with AI. It goes back more than forty years, to my early work in educational psychology and my interest in how the American family was changing. I wrote about this in 2017 in an article titled The American Family in Transition.
At the time, I was concerned that changes in family structure, technology, education, and our increasingly busy lives were unintentionally removing some of the experiences through which children historically developed responsibility, independence, and a connection.
Children once participated more directly in the work of family life. They had responsibilities that mattered to other people. They learned from adults across generations, experienced consequences, solved problems, and discovered what they were capable of doing.
Of course, earlier generations faced hardships that shouldn't be romanticized. There are plenty of things about the past I wouldn't want to bring back. But I wondered whether, in our efforts to make childhood easier and protect our children from difficulty, we were removing opportunities for them to develop the very capabilities they would need as adults.
As a father of five, and someone who was part of the self esteem movement of the 1990s, I've wrestled with that question personally. We wanted children to feel good about themselves. We wanted to build confidence and protect them from experiences that might damage their self esteem. Those were good intentions, but not every kid needed to receive a trophy.
But I began to wonder whether we sometimes confused helping children feel confident with giving them opportunities to actually become confident.
There's a difference.
Every parent wants to protect their children. We want them to be happy, successful, and spared the pain we've experienced. But when does helping become rescuing? When does protecting someone from disappointment deprive them of an opportunity to develop confidence and grit?
Those questions have followed me throughout my career.
Today, AI has given them an entirely new relevance.
What Failure Teaches Us
I was speaking recently with Steve, a business owner I've been advising, about failure and the role it plays in growth. It reminded me of something I've come to believe through my own experiences as a father, executive, coach, and endurance athlete.
Some of the most meaningful growth in our lives happens when things don't go according to plan.
When we fail, confront something we don't know how to do, or find ourselves questioning what we thought we were capable of.
I've experienced that in business, sometimes through decisions I wish I'd made differently. I've experienced it in relationships. And I've certainly experienced it through endurance sports, including training for and completing an Ironman.
There's something about committing yourself to a challenge you're not entirely sure you can do.
You prepare. You struggle. You make mistakes. You adjust. Sometimes you wonder why you started in the first place. And somewhere along the way, you discover something about yourself that you couldn't have learned simply by reading about the experience or watching someone else do it.
But struggle alone doesn't guarantee growth.
We all know people, including me, who repeat the same mistakes without changing. Growth doesn't necessarily come from experiencing difficulty. It comes from what we do with that experience.
Do we reflect? Take responsibility? Question our assumptions? Allow the experience to change us?
And perhaps just as important, who stands beside us as we figure it out, despite our mistakes?
That last question has had a profound influence on my understanding of human development and relationships.
What I Learned About Joy at Embark
For eight years, I worked closely with Alex Stavros, the former CEO of Embark Behavioral Health and a friend. We shared countless conversations about the meaning of joy. Embark's core purpose was simple but profound: To Create Joy and Heal Generations.
We worked with young people and families experiencing significant mental health challenges. Many of the kids entering treatment had experienced early trauma, disrupting their ability to form secure attachments and trust the adults responsible for caring for them. These young people didn't need more adversity to develop character. Most had already experienced far too much. What they needed was something different.
At Embark, we embraced a fundamental mantra about human behavior. No matter what was happening with a young person, no matter how difficult or dysregulated their behavior, we began with the belief that at any given moment, they were doing the very best they could.
Our responsibility wasn't to judge them or immediately tell them what they needed to change.
It was to be WITH them. To step-up beside them. And seek to understand before trying to be understood. That didn't mean abandoning boundaries or accountability. It meant recognizing that behavior has a history, and meaningful change begins with understanding the person and experiences behind it.
For young people who had learned that relationships could be unpredictable or unsafe, having someone remain present, compassionate, and consistent could help them begin to experience relationships differently. And this is where my understanding of joy began to deepen.
We often use happiness and joy interchangeably. But through my work with Alex and the philosophy we embraced at Embark, I came to understand an important distinction.
Happiness is often tied to our circumstances. We feel happy when something goes our way, when we accomplish a goal, or receive something we want. There's nothing wrong with happiness. We should enjoy it. But happiness is often fleeting. Circumstances change, and that good feeling changes with them.
Joy is something deeper. Joy can emerge through connection, relationships, service, and finding meaning in our experiences. And unlike happiness, joy doesn't require everything to be going well. We can experience joy while caring for someone who is suffering. We can find joy in a difficult shared experience. We can experience joy through sacrifice, perseverance, or realizing that our presence has made a difference in another person's life.
It's like parenting. Probably the most challenging thing you will ever do, and perhaps the most meaningful. I explored this distinction in 2023 in an article titled Beyond Happiness: The Role of Joy in Sales and Its Impact on Customer Relations, because I came to believe these principles applied far beyond my work in behavioral healthcare.
They apply to how we parent, lead, serve customers, and live our lives. What I find particularly meaningful is that joy is often relational. It isn't simply about what happens to us.
It's about what happens between us.
And sometimes, the experiences that bring us the greatest meaning are the experiences we would never have chosen if given the choice.
Helping Someone Grow Isn't the Same as Removing Their Struggle
My life mission and decades in behavioral healthcare have taught me how destructive trauma and prolonged suffering can be. I'm certainly not suggesting we should seek suffering, manufacture adversity, or withhold help from people who need it. But I've also learned that growth and healing are deeply connected to relationships.
Sometimes the most important thing we can do for another person isn't to solve their problem. It's to remain present while they work through it. To provide encouragement without taking away responsibility. To offer understanding without removing accountability or boundaries.
To help someone discover capabilities they may not yet recognize in themselves.
As a parent, that's not easy.
As a leader, it can be even harder.
We want to intervene. We want to fix things. We want to spare people the discomfort of failure.
And sometimes helping is exactly what's needed. But other times, our desire to help may unintentionally prevent someone from learning what they're capable of doing.
There's a difference between helping someone through a difficult experience and removing the experience altogether.
I think about that distinction when I work with business owners like Steve. Leadership isn't simply about knowing when to step in. It's also about knowing when to step beside someone, offer support, and allow them to take responsibility for what comes next.
Understanding someone doesn't mean excusing their behavior. And accountability doesn't have to mean abandoning empathy. I wish I'd understood that distinction as clearly earlier in my career.
What Happens When Technology Does the Difficult Work?
You don't need a reminder of everything AI can do. A student can ask AI to write an essay rather than wrestle with developing an argument. An employee can ask it to solve a problem without first attempting to understand it. A manager can generate difficult feedback without taking the time to think about the person receiving it.
In many situations, these amazing tools can genuinely improve learning, thinking, and performance. I've used AI to challenge my own assumptions, explore ideas, and become a more thoughtful writer. But there's something I keep coming back to.
Are we confusing getting an answer with developing the ability to find one?
Writing an essay isn't just about producing words. It's an opportunity to organize our thoughts, evaluate evidence, and develop an argument. Solving a problem isn't necessarily about reaching the correct answer. It's also about persistence, judgment, and confidence. And navigating a difficult conversation isn't simply about finding the right language. It's about learning empathy, courage, and responsibility.
These experiences don't always feel good. Sometimes they're frustrating, uncomfortable, and downright exhausting. But that's often where the learning happens.
Technology can help us through those experiences. It can challenge our thinking, provide feedback, and help us practice things we're not yet good at. Or it can do the work for us.
And those are two very different outcomes.
Will we become more capable because technology allows us to accomplish more? Or will we become more dependent because we have fewer opportunities to develop the capabilities those accomplishments once required?
I don't think I have the answer, but I believe it's a question we should be asking.
What Will Make the Next Generation Capable?
For most of my career, I've worked with people trying to become better at something.
Children learning to navigate the world. Families trying to reconnect. Salespeople learning to serve customers. Executives trying to become better leaders. Business owners confronting decisions they've been avoiding.
What I've learned is that growth rarely happens simply because someone receives better information. It happens when an experience challenges how they think, behave, or understand themselves. And often, that change becomes possible because someone else is willing to stand beside them.
I think back to those early questions I asked about the American family. How do children develop responsibility when they have fewer meaningful responsibilities? How do people develop judgment without opportunities to make decisions and experience consequences? And how do we discover the meaning of joy if we come to believe that a good life is one in which we never have to struggle?
Like i said, I don't have definitive answers. But I suspect the challenge facing the next generation isn't simply learning how to use increasingly powerful technology. It's learning how to remain fully human while using it. To think independently. To take responsibility. To build meaningful relationships. To sit beside someone who is struggling without feeling compelled to fix them.
And to discover that joy isn't necessarily found in a life without difficulty, but sometimes in the meaning and connection we find while navigating it together.
We've become remarkably good at making life easier. Perhaps it's time we became equally intentional about helping people become capable of living it. Because if technology increasingly allows us to avoid the experiences through which we develop competence, what will make the next generation capable?
orginally published on LinkedIn November 8, 2026





Comments